Clergy Act: A second chance at Social Security for pastors who opted out

November 18, 2026
Last revised: November 18, 2026

A new law lets clergy who opted out of Social Security opt back in. Learn what changed, who it affects and how to decide if it's right for you.
AnnaStills/Getty Images

Key takeaways

  1. A new federal law gives clergy who opted out of Social Security a one-time chance to opt back in, for tax years 2029 and 2030.
  2. Before this law, the decision to opt out couldn't be reversed, and Congress hadn't opened a similar window since 1999.
  3. Opting back in doesn't guarantee full benefits. Clergy still need to earn enough work credits to qualify.
  4. The decision affects more than retirement income. It also can affect disability, survivor and spousal benefits, and Medicare.
  5. Whether or not you opt back in, a personal retirement plan is still essential.

For decades, pastors who opted out of Social Security faced a decision that was generally considered permanent. The passage of the Clergy Act changes that by creating a limited opportunity for eligible clergy to opt back into Social Security and revisit an earlier decision in light of their current financial picture.

For many pastors, the legislation is about more than Social Security itself. It provides an opportunity to evaluate retirement readiness, income protection, health care planning and long-term financial security for themselves and their families.

What does the Clergy Act do?

The Clergy Act (H.R. 227) creates a two-year window during tax years 2029 and 2030 that allows eligible clergy who previously opted out of Social Security to revoke that exemption and participate in Social Security going forward. Prior to this legislation, clergy who elected out through IRS Form 4361 generally could not reverse that decision.

The law does not automatically restore Social Security benefits. Clergy who choose to opt back in must still satisfy the standard work-credit and contribution requirements needed to qualify for future Social Security benefits.

The legislation received broad bipartisan support, passing the House and Senate before being signed into law in October 2026.

For many ministry leaders, this marks the first meaningful opportunity in more than two decades to reconsider a decision that may have been made early in their ministry career.

How does the clergy Social Security exemption work?

Clergy occupy a unique position within the federal tax system. For income tax purposes, ministers are generally treated as employees. For Social Security and Medicare purposes, however, they are generally treated as self-employed individuals.

Historically, ministers who held qualifying religious objections to public insurance could apply for an exemption from Social Security by filing IRS Form 4361. That election generally had to be made within the first several years of ministry and, until now, was largely irreversible. Approximately 2,000 clergy receive this exemption each year. Those who opt out do not earn Social Security benefits based on their ministerial earnings.

It's important to remember that many pastors made this decision at a very different stage of life and ministry. Whether the choice was influenced by theological convictions, financial considerations or guidance received at the time, the decision often was made decades before retirement became a near-term concern. Today's conversations are less about revisiting the past and more about understanding future options.

Why the Clergy Act matters financially for pastors

When most people think about Social Security, they think about retirement income. While retirement benefits are important, Social Security can provide several forms of financial protection that may affect your family's long-term planning strategy.

Retirement income

Social Security provides a stream of lifetime income that adjusts over time for inflation. For many households, creating an equivalent source of guaranteed income through personal savings alone can be challenging and may require substantial retirement assets.

Disability protection

Social Security Disability Insurance may provide financial support if an illness or injury prevents you from continuing work. This protection can be particularly important for pastors whose ability to earn income depends on active ministry.

Survivor & family benefits

Social Security also may provide benefits for surviving spouses and dependent children. For ministry families, these benefits can serve as an important financial safety net during difficult seasons of life.

Medicare eligibility

Medicare planning is another important consideration. Premium-free Medicare Part A generally depends on an individual's work record or, in some situations, a spouse's work record. For pastors who opted out of Social Security and have limited non-ministerial employment history, understanding future healthcare coverage may become increasingly important as retirement approaches.

The financial gap some pastors face

Some pastors who opted out of Social Security expected employer-sponsored retirement plans, personal savings or other investments to provide for their retirement years. While many have accumulated significant assets, others may find that changing market conditions, unexpected expenses or evolving retirement goals create a need to reevaluate their overall income strategy.

The Clergy Act provides an opportunity to determine whether Social Security could play a role in addressing that gap.

Tax tips for pastors: A simple guide

Don’t let taxes hinder your ministry. Here are some key facts and nuances to keep in mind.

Read more

Should you opt back in? Questions to consider

The Clergy Act provides a new option, but it does not create a one-size-fits-all answer. Every pastor's financial situation is different.

As you evaluate your options, consider questions such as:

  • How many Social Security work credits have you already earned through previous employment or bi-vocational work?
  • How many working years remain before retirement?
  • Does your spouse have a Social Security earnings record that may affect available benefits?
  • How would paying self-employment tax on ministerial income, including housing allowance, affect your monthly cash flow and household budget?
  • What retirement assets have you already accumulated through a 403(b), IRA, personal investments or other savings vehicles?
  • How do retirement income, disability protection, survivor benefits and healthcare planning fit together within your overall financial plan?

Rather than focusing solely on whether to opt in, the more important question may be how Social Security fits into your broader retirement and protection strategy.

What we know (and don't know yet) about the opt-in process

We know that eligible clergy will have an opportunity during tax years 2029 and 2030 to opt back into Social Security and that standard eligibility and work-credit requirements will continue to apply.

What remains unclear is exactly how the Internal Revenue Service and the Social Security Administration will administer the process. Additional guidance is expected regarding election procedures, implementation requirements and other operational details.

Questions also remain concerning the treatment of prior ministerial service. Based on currently available information, the law appears intended to apply prospectively. However, pastors should wait for formal guidance from the IRS and Social Security Administration before making assumptions about whether past ministry years will receive credit.

The years leading up to 2029 provide an opportunity to monitor new guidance, gather information, evaluate retirement projections and make informed decisions before action is required.

Building your retirement plan, whether or not you opt in

Whether a pastor ultimately decides to opt back into Social Security or maintain the current exemption, the larger goal remains the same: building a retirement strategy that supports long-term financial confidence.

That strategy may include employer-sponsored retirement plans such as a 403(b), traditional or Roth IRAs, personal investment accounts, life insurance designed to help protect family income, and other tools that support retirement and legacy planning. The right mix will vary based on age, family circumstances, ministry timeline and overall financial goals.

The Clergy Act creates an opportunity to revisit important planning questions. It invites thoughtful conversations about retirement readiness, disability protection, survivor benefits, healthcare planning and long-term financial security. As pastors evaluate their options, the focus should be less on a single decision and more on how all the pieces fit together.

Your ministry has been about caring for others, and planning for your future is part of caring for the people who depend on you.

Talk with a financial advisor

The opt-in window doesn't begin until 2029, but now is the time to start evaluating how Social Security may fit into your retirement income strategy. A Thrivent financial advisor can help you assess your current retirement picture, understand how Social Security benefits may interact with other income sources and develop a plan aligned with your goals, family needs and calling.